[Ah! More details! Which is very very fascinating in it's own right, but there is a flaw in this system. Too many points of entry. Which means too many opportunities for corruption to sneak in.]

The nations of Thedas likewise have different forms of government. [Not really, but it looks that way from his perspective.] But the system you describe sounds susceptible to corruption. Where are the Seekers to root out misconduct and malfeasance? How is one to determine that evidence presented is not false? That this 'jury' is not making decisions out of ignorance or spite?